GTA 6 User Reviews Paint a Different Picture Than Its 99 Metascore

November 20, 2026

Grand Theft Auto VI has received near-universal acclaim from professional critics, earning an impressive 99 Metascore on Metacritic. However, player reviews tell a considerably different story. With more than 16,000 user ratings across PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, Rockstar's latest release is facing a divided reception, with negative scores slightly outnumbering positive ones on PS5 and accounting for the majority of ratings on Xbox.

The gap between critic and user scores is particularly striking for a game that arrived with enormous expectations. While reviewers have praised its technical achievements, detailed open world and ambitious presentation, a significant number of players have raised concerns about its performance, gameplay direction and overall experience.

📊 GTA 6 User Scores on Metacritic

Platform User Score Positive Mixed Negative
PlayStation 5 5.3 7.1K (45%) 1.3K (8%) 7.4K (47%)
Xbox Series X|S 4.9 381 (39%) 100 (10%) 503 (51%)


On PlayStation 5, GTA VI currently has a user score of 5.3, classified as Mixed or Average. The distribution is relatively close, although negative ratings have a slight lead over positive ones. The Xbox version has a lower score of 4.9, placing it in the Generally Unfavorable category, with negative reviews representing 51% of its ratings.

🟢Performance and Gameplay Direction Among the Main Complaints

Technical performance is one of the most recurring complaints in negative reviews. Players have criticized the 30 FPS cap on consoles, along with frame-rate drops, glitches, inconsistent performance and other technical issues. For some, these problems are particularly disappointing given the game's long development cycle and premium price.

However, performance is only part of the criticism. Another recurring argument is that GTA VI has moved too far away from the formula that made the franchise so popular. Some players describe the experience as closer to The Sims or Red Dead Redemption 2 than a traditional Grand Theft Auto game.

The emphasis on realism, everyday activities and slower-paced gameplay has become one of the most divisive aspects of the release. While some players appreciate the added immersion and attention to detail, others feel these elements come at the expense of freedom, satire and the chaotic gameplay they expect from GTA.

The story and its protagonists have also received mixed reactions. Some reviews criticize the pacing, lengthy dialogue and characterization of Jason and Lucia, while others feel the missions are too restrictive and offer little meaningful innovation over GTA V. Complaints about expensive editions, additional content, and the lack of a physical disc have also appeared among the negative reviews.

🔴Players Praising the Open World and Immersion

On the other side, positive reviews frequently highlight Leonida's detailed open world, impressive visuals, NPC interactions and the amount of content available to explore. For these players, the game's greatest achievement is how alive its environment feels, with random encounters, side activities and countless small details rewarding exploration.

Jason and Lucia's relationship and the overall storytelling have also received praise. Several players describe the narrative as engaging and appreciate the more cinematic approach to character development, while others see the influence of Red Dead Redemption 2 as a natural evolution of Rockstar's open-world formula.

Interestingly, the slower opening chapters are another point of disagreement. Some players consider the early hours tedious and unnecessarily restrictive, while others believe the gradual introduction of the characters and world makes the experience more rewarding as the story progresses. Several positive reviewers have also reported relatively few technical problems during their playthroughs, despite acknowledging that the 30 FPS limit is far from ideal.

🟡A Divided Reception Over What GTA Should Be

Looking at the written reviews, one of the clearest disagreements concerns the direction of the franchise itself. Features that some players consider unnecessary realism and tedious simulation elements are exactly what others praise as the biggest improvements in this installment. The same applies to the influence of Red Dead Redemption 2. For some, GTA VI feels like a successful combination of Rockstar's two major franchises. For others, that influence has diluted the identity and freedom that made Grand Theft Auto unique.

With a 99 Metascore but user scores below 5.5 on both platforms, GTA VI highlights a clear divide between professional critics and players. Ultimately, the disagreement goes beyond technical issues: it reflects two very different expectations of what the next Grand Theft Auto should deliver.

The contrast becomes even more interesting when compared with Grand Theft Auto V. On Metacritic, the Xbox 360 version received 79% positive user reviews, while the PS4 version reached 84%. However, the number of ratings was considerably lower than the current volume for GTA VI, making a direct comparison difficult. The difference may also reflect how player feedback and platforms like Metacritic have evolved over the years, when user scores did not necessarily receive the same level of attention they do today.

NEWS THAT MAY INTEREST YOU